Saturday, January 12, 2013

My Sports Hernia Experience

 I have never blogged before but after a complicated injury that has set me back from running marathons and dropping out of my target Boston Qualification race, to my long and frustrating road to recovery, I felt compelled to write about my experience.  More importantly to spread the word about the lack of information on doctors who specialize in groin injuries in hopes to help a fellow athlete that may be facing the same injury.  I am an avid runner and have completed several half and full marathons. In August while I was in mid marathon training for my third full marathon in 2012, I developed dull ache in my left lower abdomen/ groin area. When the symptoms first came on it was a gradual onset and there wasn't a notable day that it occurred.  It only bothered me with physical activity such as running.  The strange thing about it was that it would be uncomfortable for a mile or two and would then disappear allowing me to continue training for several weeks. However, it got to the point where that discomfort level increased significantly eventually causing me to reduce and alter my marathon training and eventually causing me to drop out of the ING Hartford marathon at mile 9 which would have been my 6th full marathon. I scheduled my first of many frustrating orthopedic appointments to confirm my suspicion. I just knew that I had a Sports Hernia though I hoped for the best. A sports hernia is usually classified as long standing groin discomfort or pain and is NOT actually a hernia but more of a tear in the groin where our adductors, rectus abdominals , and external obliques all join near the pubic area.  A Sports Hernia is often called Athletic Pubalgia or even Gilmore's groin.   It is unbelievable to me that so many doctors have little understanding of what a Sports Hernia really entails and that they have little informations as to who to send you to. Due to my rising frustration I took to the internet in hopes to find a groin expert.  I spent several days  research hoping I could find somebody local that could help me out.  One day I got lucky as to how I Google searched the topic and found a blog by an athlete by the name of Pat Dwyer blogging about his very similar experience with Athletic Pubalgia.  He in fact had the surgery for Athletic Pubalgia in Massachusetts out of UMASS. Great stuff! I googled the orthopedic doctor he used (Dr. Brian Busconi) and immediately came to the realization that this doctor and a local general surgeon had several publications related to athletic pubalgia. I made my appointment with Busconi. He was two hour commute but worth every mile. He conducted X-rays of the area and read my MRI and determined that I had slight cam impingement in my hip as well as Athletic Pubalgia and believed my hip issue was asymptomatic.  Dr. Brian Busconi attempted an injection into the groin and I was told to rest (once again). I rested and continued ongoing PT, stretching, ART, core strength but no relief just decreasing fitness and increasing frustration. I made the call back to Busconi who recommend me seeing the general surgeon. Dr. Demetrius Litwin, the same guy in the publications and exactly the fella I read about in the blogs. Very recently I met up with general surgeon Demetrius Litwin at UMASS Memorial Hospital. At first I was very uneasy about the whole deal because researching the internet and running forums, it appeared that there were two ways that doctors fix this type of injury.  These methods were either through an arthroscopic mesh overlay procedure and open surgery suture technique.  From my findings, many athletes were having bad outcomes with the arthroscopic procedure and later had to go under the knife again.  Based on my research , there were only three doctors that people talked about who operated via open surgery.  Dr. William Meyers located in Philidelphia (the guru in Sports Hernia surgeries), Dr. William Brown out of California, and Dr. Muschaweck in Germany.  After calling Dr. William Meyers office (where all NHL, NFL players go) I learned that he no longer deals with insurance companies.  My luck was beginning to run out. It all came down to my visit with Dr. Litwin and the technique he used for his procedures.    I'm happy to say that Dr. Litwin along with Dr. Busconi are the right men for the job. Before Dr. Meyers worked in Philadelphia he recruited Dr. Litwin to work side by side with him. He uses the same open procedure as Meyers and doesn't believe in using mesh for this type of injury. They consider it pelvic floor repair. I am finally scheduled for surgery on February 4th and it is truly exciting to finally see the light at the end of the tunnel and I cant wait to get back to the competitive addiction within sport I have grown to love.

22 comments:

  1. Best of luck with your surgery and recovery. I am the product of a surgery-gone-wrong with Dr. Muschaweck from Germany. I now spend my time warning people to AVOID her at all costs. She is very hands-off once you leave Germany to return to the States. To date, I am now left with chronic groin pain, nerve damage and nerve entrapment. And BTW, yes, I did see Meyers in Philly and I was unimpressed. He puts on a good show but his demeanor and bedside manner were atrocious. He is accustomed to working with pro athletes that don't ask questions but just do as they're told by their trainers. When Meyers learns that you are NOT a pro athlete, his recovery success rate for you goes down to 50%. But again, best of luck with your surgery and a lasting recovery.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry to hear that! I am 2 weeks post op and feeling great as far as the athletic pubalgia goes. The doctors repaired a large abdominal rectus tear. It took so long to get diagnosed that I feel my hips and all other surrounding muscles are all messed up because of guarding and helping me stabilize my core. Have you experienced any guarding due to your injury prior to surgery?

      Delete
    2. Hey Kevin, it has been a very long time since I visited anything on the internet regarding sports hernias and I ran across my entry here from nearly a year ago. I hope you are fully recovered by now. We all deserve a pain-free life. Unfortunately, my post-hernia pain syndrome has deteriorated considerably over the past year and I spend most of my time in bed because of the pain. I'm currently on disability and I have applied for Social Security Disability at this point as there really is no end in sight to this being fixed or resolved. I've seen a variety of doctors' name mentioned that I could contact but none of them want to interact with you unless you come to see them in person and I just don't have the resources any longer to get transported to doctors that are many hours away from me, not to mention the absolute pain from travel and sitting upright. Plus, most doctors don't want to deal with you if you are coming to them from a previous surgery - almost like they don't want to fix other doctors' screw-ups. Anyway, I still advise people to avoid traveling abroad (definitely STAY AWAY from Muschaweck) for this type of surgery as you pretty much give away any legal rights to litigation should that avenue be needed.

      Delete
  2. Kevin-

    Your story sounds EXACTLY like mine except I'm having trouble finding anyone to do this surgery. I hadn't heard of anyone out of Boston doing this.

    You must be several months post-op now. How is it going? I have a ton of questions about the surgery, insurance, recovery. If you'd be willing to email me, it'd really help. It's just a non-stop pain and I don't seem to be getting better. I want to run again so bad.

    Thanks,

    Roger

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey man...sorry for the delay in reading this post. I hope by now you have had a lot of your questions answered if not I will be more than glad to help you out and answer all your questions. Shoot me an email for you and I will shoot you my phone number if you'd rather chat instead of the back and fourth in email.....

      Delete
  3. Hey Kevin,

    I've read both your blog posts and I'm glad that you had a successful surgery and seemed to have recovered well. I've been reading up on hernia for the past couple of days ever since a friend of mine was diagnosed with it. I must appreciate your effort for putting to words how it was to cope with this condition and the challenge to find reliable and experienced hernia doctors. I realise that it has been several months since your surgery and you don't seem to have made any blog posts since. But one more post conveying how your long term recovery has been would really help those of us who have been completely caught off guard by this condition. Information from those who have been through this is much more reassuring.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Will....Much agreeed! I was actually planning on writing a follow up blog on my progress and was waiting on a full completion to training and running my comeback marathon, however, as my luck would have it I am now dealing with a minor nagging nerve issue in my leg which is stemming from my back. Recover from my Sports Hernia surgery was fantastic. Long and short of it was that I resumed running activities aprox. 14 weeks post op and took it very slow. After about a month of running and core work I was able to jump into marathon training. I was sore every now and again due to the mileage increase and maybe some scar tissue build up restriction but the pain was super managable. I am pain free today in the groin....so a success....a full blog to follow!!!

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

      Delete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. After 6 months of increasing pain and spasms, I've finally been referred to Dr. Meyers. I'm just getting a bit scared by what I keep reading online about sports hernias. I also have a labral tear, but no matter what I read no one seems to have been as disabled by spasms all through the abdomen and pelvis as I seem to be....does anyone have any advice? I'm getting worried! I read that this doctor doesn't take insurance, that some people are disabled for life and in pain, etc. It seems like my health is in the balance here and I don't want to make a bad decision, especially if it will cost this much money.

    Help? (I talk to the hip specialist Monday, but have heard from his assistant that he is recommending I see Meyers as well.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Shoot me an email and I'll give u a number to contact me....it will be much easier to go back and forth

      Delete
    2. Curious where you are out with the Sports Hernia, I to have a labral tear

      Delete
    3. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  6. Hi Kevin. Thanks so much for posting this. I would like to chat with you if you are open to corresponding about this. I had sports hernia surgery with Dr Meyers in March of this year, and it is now 4 months later and I keep having setbacks when I increase my mileage (off for a week and a half now from running). I do core exercises, but I was wondering what type you do and how your recovery running plan went. Any guidance would be greatly appreciated. Also, how do I email you? Sincerely, David

    ReplyDelete
  7. For more information about click this Hernia surgery

    ReplyDelete
  8. I stumbled here, like Kevin, getting gradual increasing pain from running/training for 5K-1/2 marathons and now needing help, and going to Dr. Meyers who did a standing pelvic x-ray and his very specific MRI positions. I have sx in my right groin and front of hip and can only gallop one legged if I want to try to run at all. His office does take insurance, it is that the insurance companies are now refusing to pay for the procedure, at least as of 2016, and I don't have a spare $12K to put toward my "hobby." I have IBC's 17 page Med Policy Bulletin refuting the efficacy of surgery vs. conservative care but when I researched it (I am a lawyer) it is just bullshit, most of their supporting cites (including Meyers and Litvin) strongly suggest that it is well-diagnosable from exam and MRI and that surgery is more likely to produce recovery over conservative aggressive PT since it is humanly impossible to do the water therapy, extensive and expensive tools needed, time, etc. like full time devoted prof. athletes have the ability to do. I can't just do that stuff 7 days a week, or even 3-5. I'd like to be able to take walks with my wife at least, but now I can't keep up with her.

    So my $12K question to you, Kevin, is, did your insurance actually pay for your surgery?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Go see dr william Brown in san francisco. He is a no nonsense doctor who has been doing these surgeries forever. Tell him exactly where it hurts.

      Delete
    2. Ken from Philly, Please tell me, have you gone ahead with surgery? Did you check into Dr. Brown in CA?

      Delete
    3. To Unknown, have you seen Dr. Brown in CA?

      Delete
  9. Interesting stuff! Your symptoms all sound the same as mine. I see Busconi today

    ReplyDelete